Book Reviews
37 essays
Reviews and reflections on books about peace, justice, nonviolence, and the people who practice them. McCarthy is a generous but discerning critic, covering works on Gandhi, Dorothy Day, the Berrigan brothers, nonviolent resistance movements, prison reform, and animal rights. Each review is less a literary judgment than an occasion to explore ideas — using the book under review as a launching point for McCarthy's own arguments about war, peace, and the moral life.
-
A Cry Unheard - The Medical Consequences of Loneliness (Review)
A book that names what medicine rarely does: loneliness as a medical condition, killing more quietly than heart disease and more widely than cancer.1,282 words · 5 min read
-
A Force More Powerful (Book Review)
The book-length case that nonviolent resistance is not idealism but strategy — a century of evidence that force without weapons works.1,091 words · 4 min read
-
A Force More Powerful (Film Review)
The film that answers the question every student asks — 'but would nonviolence stop a Hitler?' — with historical evidence instead of theory.1,055 words · 4 min read
-
A People Adrift - The Crisis of the American Catholic Church (Review)
Supportive friends invite you to join a billion-member organization that is male-run, land-rich, and undemocratic — and then wonder why you hesitate.1,406 words · 5 min read
-
Anatomy of an Execution (Review)
The life and death of Douglas Christopher Thomas — anatomy of a Virginia execution and the system that made it possible.789 words · 3 min read
-
Bicycle - The History (Review)
Except for golf, no sport has produced literature quite like the bicycle — a 470-page history of the machine that democratized human movement.823 words · 3 min read
-
CLASS DISMISSED (Review)
A year inside an American high school, seen from the parental sideline — where involvement in a child's education is the variable that changes everything.986 words · 3 min read
-
Dear World—A Global Odyssey (Review)
A World War II veteran's global odyssey of remorse and reconciliation — one of those Americans who obeyed orders to kill and came home unable to stop asking why.1,268 words · 5 min read
-
Doing Time for Peace (Book Review)
The oral histories of Catholic Workers who went to prison for peace — Rosalie Riegle collects the voices of people who meant what they said about nonviolence.940 words · 3 min read
-
Double Crossed - The Catholic Church and American Nuns (Review)
Nearly 100,000 American nuns left their orders since Vatican II, and only a trickle are joining — what went wrong between the church and its most devoted women.563 words · 2 min read
-
First Service - Andrea Jaeger’s Second Life (Review)
Andrea Jaeger’s future seemed assured — tennis stardom, large paydays — until she chose a second life of service over the first life of fame.273 words · 1 min read
-
Four Books About the Game of Golf
Four books about golf, reviewed as the U.S. Open comes to Winged Foot — because the game's literature deserves the same attention as its tournaments.1,540 words · 6 min read
-
Golfing with God (Review)
A novel in which God plays golf — reviewed by a man who once scored a 65 in competition and has been seeking the divine in the game ever since.810 words · 3 min read
-
Handbook for Mortals (Review)
A guide for facing serious illness that does what most medical books won't — treats dying as something that happens to a whole person, not just a body.827 words · 3 min read
-
IN SEARCH OF TIGER (Review)
Among golf's beat reporters, Tom Callahan is a rarity — a writer who got close to Tiger Woods and came back with a book worth reading.750 words · 3 min read
-
In the Hands of the Great Spirit (Review)
Twenty thousand years of American Indian history told whole — the book that starts long before Columbus and doesn't end with the reservation.914 words · 3 min read
-
Julia’s Mother (Review)
A pediatric emergency room doctor learns that his talents are needed by more than the children — the parents who bring them in are breaking too.1,224 words · 4 min read
-
Oh, Johnny by Jim Lehrer (Review)
Jim Lehrer's nineteenth novel sends a Maryland country boy to war — fiction that knows what the nonfiction can't quite say about combat and loss.475 words · 1 min read
-
On Turning Sixty-Five - Notes From the Field (Review)
A man of opinions, wonder, and unsolicited advice turns sixty-five and takes notes from the field — the field being his own aging body.1,234 words · 4 min read
-
Prisoners - A Muslim and Jew Across the Middle East Divide (Review)
A Jewish boy from Long Island and a Palestinian prisoner — Jeffrey Goldberg's memoir of the unlikely friendship that formed across the divide.682 words · 2 min read
-
Profiles in Courage for Our Time (Review)
Caroline Kennedy updates her father's book with new profiles in political courage — and McCarthy asks whether courage in politics has gotten any easier.579 words · 2 min read
-
Review - A Force More Powerful and Other Peace Books
A review arguing that nonviolence is not a creed for the naïve but a proven strategy — and that the books documenting it deserve wider reading.1,352 words · 5 min read
-
Sisters - Catholic Nuns and the Making of America (Review)
Any Catholic has a favorite nun story — this book collects them all, from the frontier schoolrooms to the inner-city hospitals where sisters built America.795 words · 3 min read
-
Thank You, Anarchy (Review)
There's that word again — anarchy — but etymologically it means without a ruler, not without rules, and Occupy Wall Street took the distinction seriously.728 words · 2 min read
-
The Beloved Community - Faith and the Civil Rights Movement (Review)
How faith shaped the civil rights movement and what happened to the beloved community after the marches ended and the cameras left.829 words · 3 min read
-
The Forgetting - Alzheimer’s and the Meaning of Loss (Review)
Reagan proclaimed National Alzheimer’s Month in 1982; a decade later the disease found him — a book about the epidemic of forgetting.1,221 words · 4 min read
-
The Future of Peace (Review)
A slightly grandiose book about the future of peace — McCarthy enjoys the ambition while questioning whether the legwork matches the claim.764 words · 3 min read
-
The Longest Trip Home (Review)
John Grogan's memoir of the longest trip home — the one that leads back to the parents, the faith, and the questions that never got answered the first time.913 words · 3 min read
-
The Mysterious Montague (Review)
The true tale of a golfer who could outdrive anyone, mixed with Hollywood glamour and armed robbery — a mystery the sport has never quite explained.716 words · 2 min read
-
The Pig Who Sang to the Moon (Review)
A book that takes seriously what farmers and slaughterhouse workers already know: farm animals have emotional lives, and we'd rather not think about it.858 words · 3 min read
-
The Pleasure of Their Company (Review)
Doris Grumbach in relaxed conversational prose on the pleasure of solitude — a book that makes being alone sound like the richest company.1,250 words · 5 min read
-
The Soul of Baseball and Other Baseball Books (Review)
Buck O'Neil played in the Negro League when America wouldn't let him play anywhere else — a road trip through his America, where the soul of baseball lives.1,182 words · 4 min read
-
Three Books on the Nonviolent Movement
Reviews of three essential books on nonviolence — Chernus on the history of the idea, Schell on the power of it, Wittner on the movement to abolish the bomb.859 words · 3 min read
-
Unholy Ghost - Writers on Depression (Review)
Twenty-three writers name what the word 'depression' can't: a vagueness that comes nowhere near the suffering it's supposed to describe.860 words · 3 min read
-
Walking With Jack and Loopers (Golf Book Review)
Two books about caddying — the grand claim that no sport has produced a finer literature of service, devotion, and carrying someone else's burden.960 words · 3 min read
-
Was World War II a “Necessary War”? (Ken Burns film review)
Ken Burns calls World War II a necessary war — McCarthy asks whether it was necessary to firebomb Tokyo and vaporize Hiroshima.708 words · 2 min read
-
Why America Fights (Review)
A month after 9/11, American bombers began killing in Afghanistan — a book that traces the propaganda patterns from the Philippines to Iraq.948 words · 3 min read