Criminal Justice & Death Penalty
8 essays
Essays on the American death penalty and the broader failures of the criminal justice system. Central to this collection is the case of Joseph Giarratano, a Virginia death row inmate whose story McCarthy followed for years, and Vicki Schieber, a mother who lost her daughter to murder yet became an advocate against execution. These pieces examine Virginia's notorious 21-day rule, the moral bankruptcy of state killing, and the question of whether a society that claims to value life can answer violence with more violence.
-
A Man of Letters -- Joseph Giarratano on Death Row
Students at American University honor a man who hasn't been seen in public since 1978, when Virginia sent him to death row on a conviction that won't hold up.624 words · 2 min read
-
Dear Joe -- Waiting for Justice in Virginia
In February 1991, McCarthy traveled to Richmond to say goodbye to a friend and watch him die — then a governor's commutation came hours before the chair.836 words · 3 min read
-
Eddie Ellis and the Second Chance
Two years out of a fifteen-year stretch that took him through six prisons including a Colorado supermax, Eddie Ellis is trying to prove that second chances work.743 words · 2 min read
-
Modern Slavery in the Global Economy
A Cameroonian teenager enslaved as a housekeeper in suburban Maryland — modern slaveholders don't carry whips, but the exploitation is the same.837 words · 3 min read
-
Schieber- NCR
When the U.S. bishops finally opposed the death penalty in the 1980s, unanimity was absent — and the moral argument still had to be made, one diocese at a time.754 words · 3 min read
-
The Case Against the Death Penalty in Virginia
Virginia's electric chair, built by Thomas Jefferson in 1800, and the friend McCarthy went to watch die in it — a case against state killing made personal.836 words · 3 min read
-
Vicki Schieber and the Case Against Execution
Most abolitionists are armchair opinionators; Vicki Schieber, whose daughter was murdered, opposes execution from a place the rest of us cannot reach.765 words · 3 min read
-
Virginia’s 21-Day Rule and the Case of Joseph Giarratano
Four men freed from Virginia’s death row since 1972, and the rule that nearly killed them: twenty-one days to present new evidence, then the door shuts forever.1,766 words · 7 min read